Jonathan Taylor vs Christian McCaffrey
Comparison based on 2026 results · Full-PPR scoring, ranked by last-season total points · the verdict also weighs 2027 projections, availability and ADP
PPR pts (season)
146144
146PPR pts (season)144
PPR pts / game
18.320.6
18.3PPR pts / game20.6
Games played
87
8Games played7
Rush yards
610389
610Rush yards389
Receptions
2134
21Receptions34
Floor (p10)
6.713.8
6.7Floor (p10)13.8
Ceiling (p90)
29.230.7
29.2Ceiling (p90)30.7
Consistency %
6386
63Consistency %86
Proj pts/game (2027)
18.020.6
18.0Proj pts/game (2027)20.6
Proj games (2027)
1110
11Proj games (2027)10
ADP (lower = pricier)
9.810
9.8ADP (lower = pricier)10
THE PICKJonathan Taylor
Jonathan Taylor holds the 2026 edge: 2 PPR points over the season, finishing #17 overall vs #20. That said, McCaffrey was the steadier week-to-week option (86% consistency vs 63%); our 2027 projection actually flips the call — 20.6 vs 18 projected points per game in McCaffrey's favor; and McCaffrey closed the season hotter (+0.9 vs his average), so the gap may be tightening. Jonathan Taylor remains the preferred Full-PPR pick.
Based on 2026 results plus 2027 projections and live ADP · Computed by TurfSplit from official box scores — not an opinion poll.
Game-by-game form · 2026BOTH CHARTS SHARE ONE SCALE
Jonathan Taylor — last 8 gamesLAST 5 VS AVG -2.1
Christian McCaffrey — last 7 gamesLAST 5 VS AVG +0.9